No silver lining as crows come home
November 4, 2004
A distraught young person called me in tears on the morning after the election, amid the ashes of the terrible defeat for the Democrats and for liberal hopes. I tried to console her by saying that in 1980, things looked pretty dark after Ronald Reagan and the Republicans swept into power, yet only 12 years later, we had a draft-dodging adulterer ensconced in the White House and the Democrats back in control of Congress for a couple of years.
This didn't help, so I rushed her back to 1956, when Eisenhower was reelected and the skies looked dark. But only four years later, we had a Democratic war hero-adulterer on the parapet of Camelot and the Summer of Love only seven years down the road.
By this time she was crying so hard she could barely hold her cellphone, an instrument owned by all those millions that hopeful Democrats kept explaining the pollsters were overlooking. I told her I'd call back in an hour or so as soon as I'd rounded up a silver lining, though there's none she would relish. I could scarcely accuse her of being in a generation that turned out to be part of the Democrats' innumerable problems. So much for Rock the Vote and for Eminem. The youth vote (18 to 24) stayed the same as in 2000. The turnout among the 25 to 35 cohort was 4 percent less than in 2000.
Youth, so an exit poll survey (by the Edison Media Research Group and Mitofsky International) tells us, had the same concerns, in the same order of priorities as the older echelons of the voting population: From the top: the economy, moral values, Iraq and terrorism. Bush cleaned up on moral values and the war on terror, with his own supporters rejecting the equation he himself made, between the war on terror and the war in Iraq (where Kerry had the edge).
Moral values … this brings us to the fact that the United States is a Christian nation, as most recently confirmed by one of those regular surveys conducted by the University of Chicago, which reported in 2002 that the adult population of the homeland is 53 percent Protestant, 25 percent Catholic, 3 percent Christians of some other stripe, 3 percent other religions, 2 percent Jewish and 14 percent holding "no religion." Of the Christians, 25 percent go to church once a week or more.
Right after the sad call from the young thing Wednesday morning, I got a message from my old friend Wilbur, who lives not far from Spartanburg, S.C., the buckle of the Bible Belt. "We did it," he crowed in high good hunmor. "The bible thumpers and the gun toters." True, in serious part.
The Democrats spent the year wasting money and passion attacking Ralph Nader, whose early predictions of his ultimate drawing power at the polls turned out to be on the money. If the Democrats had wanted to identify a serious saboteur of their chances, they should have homed in on Mayor Gavin Newsom of San Francisco, whose OK to gay marriage saw all those same sex couples on the steps of City Hall embracing, on every front page and nightly news in America. Ohio had a proposition banning gay marriage, and the drive to put it on the ballot and push it to victory brought Christians out in their hundreds of thousands, marching to the polls across the rubble of their state's economy.
The Republicans rallied their base. The Democrats failed at this crucial test of the vitality of any mass political party. The South has gone. John Edwards failed to recover a single state. How much better it would have been for Kerry to have had the Rustbelt's Dick Gephardt on the ticket, where he would have won Missouri and maybe Iowa and put Kerry in the White House; or Bill Richardson of New Mexico.
The day of the vote I picked up the pre-election issue of the New York Review, with the cream of the liberal intelligentsia pouring out denunciations of Bush. Scarcely one could bring himself (yes, the 14 were all men, most, if not all, white) to mention the difficult name Kerry. Russell Baker is one who did, and he wrote exactly what I've said in column after column this year: "The case against John Kerry is that not being George Bush is an inadequate qualification for being president of the United States."
Any successful presidential candidate has to project himself as a chapter in the American epic: the man from Plains; the man from Hope, traveling through light and shade, but always the same voyager in his inner essence. Where was Kerry from? Somewhere in the greater Boston area, a transient between one of six mansions. What was his inner essence? Kerry was like a man in front of an ATM machine, trying to figure out which of his credit cards had a positive balance: the war card, the peace card, the prosecutor card. Whatever positive balance he came up with never impressed enough of the voters. Bush? Every time someone excavated his idle, privileged youth, his evasions of military service, his drunken years, his business disasters, even his failures in the first hours of 9-11, all it did was confirm to most Americans that lives have many chapters and rebirths along the journey to redemption.
Nov. 2, 2004, marks a terrible defeat for the liberal elites, whether represented by Paul Krugman in the New York Times, by Michael Moore in his baseball cap, by the New York Review, or by that vast complex of delusion and self-aggrandizement known as the Democratic Party. Its establishment is truly in crisis now, from the labor leaders who squandered millions in vehement efforts to keep Ralph Nader off the ballot to the public interest groups that gave Kerry the green light to waffle on all the crucial issues, to the "strategists" who got their cut on the campaign ads and got it all wrong. I hadn't the heart to warn the weeping young thing that they'll be back in 2008, as wrong as ever and that mass movements have to build up momentum over decades, not in the span of one election campaign and a lot of electronic hype.
Alexander Cockburn is coeditor with Jeffrey St. Clair of the muckraking newsletter CounterPunch. He is also co-author of the new book "Dime's Worth of Difference: Beyond the Lesser of Two Evils," available through www.counterpunch.com. To find out more about Alexander Cockburn and read features by other columnists and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate Web page at www.creators.com.
COPYRIGHT 2004 CREATORS SYNDICATE, INC.
Email this article to a friend
"Ten good groups that need help"
December 29, 2004
"Don't they know it's Christmas? It's moral outrage time!"
December 22, 2004
"Be a hero on 805 percent a year"
December 19, 2004
"Animals don't vote"
December 19, 2004
"Gary Webb and the art of the CIA cover-up"
December 15, 2004
"Politicize the CIA? You've got to be kidding!"
December 1, 2004
"Let them drink sand"
November 23, 2004
"Now for the really bad news"
November 11, 2004
"No silver lining as crows come home"
November 4, 2004
"From Detroit to Baghdad: Intimations of Ed Seitz"
October 27, 2004
"The free speech movement and John Kerry"
October 18, 2004
"'There are no innocents'"
October 8, 2004
"Why Nazis banned Fraktura"
September 28, 2004
"Ralph, go to the West Bank, go to Baghdad!"
September 23, 2004
"The stench of doom"
September 2, 2004
August 26, 2004
"Kerry makes a strong case for Nader"
August 9, 2004
"Presidential elections 2004: Not as big a deal as they say"
August 9, 2004
July 28, 2004
"Nader and the conspiracy of silence"
July 22, 2004
"Boston awaits dead party"
July 14, 2004
"Venezuela: the gang's all here!"
June 25, 2004
"Reagan in truth and fiction"
June 10, 2004
"Kerry gives CPR to stricken prez"
May 27, 2004
"The empire, seen from Oceanside"
May 21, 2004
"Greenlights for torture"
May 13, 2004
"Torture: as American as apple pie"
May 5, 2004
"Stupid leaders, useless spies, angry world"
April 29, 2004
"Clouds loom over Kerry challenge"
April 22, 2004
"Bush, Kerry and empire"
April 19, 2004
"Pulitzers and Prozac"
April 8, 2004
"Gay marriage: a step back in freedom's faltering march"
March 16, 2004
"Understanding the world with Paul Sweezy"
March 10, 2004
"The uproar over Nader"
March 3, 2004
"Winning with Ralph Nader"
February 25, 2004
"On not believing in John Kerry"
February 19, 2004
February 11, 2004
"Ladies and Gentleman: President Edwards! (After all, he did win South Carolina)"
February 9, 2004
"McNamara: The Sequel"
February 9, 2004
"The fog of cop-out: Robert McNamara 10, Errol Morris 0"
January 28, 2004
"Havoc in the cornfields"
January 20, 2004
"Bush and Iraq: the truth at last"
January 16, 2004
"Bush as Hitler? Let's be fair"
January 8, 2004
Read Articles by Year:
2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000