Skip to main content

From Columbus to Oklahoma City: A Bipartisan Judicial Rebuke of Politicians Policing Citizens’ Ballot Petitions

//
News
Image
David Yost

For more than a century, the citizen-led ballot initiative has served as democracy’s emergency brake—a constitutional guarantee that when statehouses ignore the public will, voters can take their case directly to the people. Yet across the country, politicians have quietly discovered a powerful way to jam that brake before a campaign even starts: executive gatekeeping. ​

The Oklahoma Supreme Court slammed the door on that tactic in McVay v. Lepak, becoming the first state supreme court in the nation to formally adopt the Sixth Circuit’s landmark Ohio First Amendment doctrine in Brown v. Yost. ​For Ohioans who have watched Attorney General Dave Yost repeatedly reject citizen-drafted petition summaries over wording disputes, the Oklahoma decision is more than distant legal news. 

It is a major constitutional milestone confirming that when state officials act as copy editors over citizens’ political speech, they violate the First Amendment. ​In McVay v. Lepak, the Oklahoma high court struck down Senate Bill 1027—a sweeping 2025 overhaul engineered to choke off citizen initiatives—declaring the law unconstitutional and void in its entirety. 

Alongside county-by-county signature caps and circulator restrictions, S.B. 1027 forced citizens to submit their petition’s short summary—known as the "gist"—to Oklahoma’s Secretary of State for pre-circulation approval while dictating what that summary had to say. ​To strike down that executive speech-vetting, Justice Noma Gurich’s majority opinion looked straight to Columbus and the Sixth Circuit’s 2025 decision in Brown v. Yost. ​In Brown, Ohio citizens seeking to put a constitutional amendment ending qualified immunity on the ballot had their summary rejected eight times by Attorney General Yost under Ohio’s "fair and truthful" certification statute, burning months of critical signature-gathering time. 

Yost argued that vetting a petition summary wasn't regulating speech at all—it was merely administering the mechanics of lawmaking. ​The Sixth Circuit dismantled that defense, holding that a petition summary is core political advocacy used by citizens to persuade fellow voters, and that giving an executive official subjective veto power over how citizens summarize their own measure makes the state an unconstitutional editor of private speech. ​

The Oklahoma Supreme Court embraced that reasoning word for word. Noting that S.B. 1027’s summary rules both compel specific speech and limit what may be said in the gist, the court cited Brown v. Yost—pointing out that the Sixth Circuit recently addressed a similar Ohio statute—and concluded that the analysis is persuasive and applicable to executive gist requirements. Grounding its ruling in strict First Amendment scrutiny, the court held that forcing citizens to clear an executive official’s ideological or stylistic hurdle before circulating a petition imposes an impermissible prior restraint on political expression. ​

For legal and political observers in Ohio, McVay v. Lepak carries unmistakable strategic weight. While an Oklahoma ruling is persuasive rather than binding in Ohio courts, it is the first state supreme court decision to elevate Brown v. Yost into a broader, cross-state constitutional standard. Even more tellingly, the Oklahoma majority included Republican-appointed justices—proving that protecting grassroots petitioners from government censorship is a bedrock constitutional principle, not a partisan talking point. ​

Ohio’s political establishment has long treated Brown v. Yost as a localized inconvenience to be litigated around and delayed. McVay v. Lepak proves the opposite: a bipartisan judicial consensus is rapidly solidifying around the Sixth Circuit’s core insight. 

​Voters do not need an Attorney General or a Secretary of State to pre-approve how fellow citizens explain a ballot measure on a clipboard. From Columbus to Oklahoma City, the courts are delivering the same message to politicians: get out of the editing business, and let the people speak. ​


Miss Cynthia Brown ​is the founder of the Heartbeat Movement Inc., ​founder of theThe Ohio Coalition to End Qualified Immunity, ​Committee Chair for Protecting Ohioans' Constitutional Rights Initiative Committee, ​founder of The Ohio Coalition for Police Accountability and Transparency, oceqi.org.