Why are Columbus City School principals recruiting students to charter schools?
The latest list of school closures in Columbus includes Mifflin High School, a building tucked back into a winding neighborhood on the city’s northeast side.
My first impression was it was a nice school, but such is my impression of most school buildings after working in my current Columbus City Schools high school building for six years. The vast majority of schools are “nicer” than the one I work in; they at least feel like a school when you walk into it instead of a prison.
Students will often say school feels like prison, and most adults shrug them off with a dismissive comment that backhands their work ethic, as if the students themselves are not aware of or able to remark on their own conditions.
They’re not wrong. From brutalist architecture, mandatory metal detectors, backpack searches, locked restrooms and food shipped in which somehow passes as edible, the public education system mirrors the incarceration system in more ways than not.
And yet students are still organizing to save their schools despite the adults in their lives largely failing to take their concerns seriously or pay half a mind to the powers the district administration and school board continue to serve, which continue to conflict directly with the interests of the working class and the wellbeing of its children.
For example, students at Mifflin High School are trying to save their school, even though the building leader, Principal Joe Krabill, was sending emails showing he tried to recruit students to charter schools from September to May in the 2025-2026 school year (emails I obtained through public records request are pictured above).
This may not seem surprising after my Substack post exposing the Marion-Franklin principal inviting in the exact same charter school, Early College Academy, to meet with and recruit their students.
But it still begs the question why these students can’t complete their educational journeys through their own public school. Why is the best support these principals have, for often our most vulnerable students, the act of showing them the door?
Perhaps it’s because Columbus City Schools (CCS) has a pattern of closing programs and alternative education settings outside the realm of general K-12 education which prove beneficial to its students.
I’d like to think this was a one-off communication between the Mifflin High School principal and Josh Johnson, the Principal/Dean of Students at the charter school Early College Academy, but other communications
I obtained through public records requests lead one to believe this is an ongoing relationship between yet another CCS principal and charter school principal.
Not only does the Mifflin High School principal make phone calls to the charter school regarding students, but he followed up with birth certificates and transcripts while informing the Early College Academy charter school principal when he could count on the students arriving.
I don’t share these public records to bring harm to my district. I share them to report on the apparent collusion that is happening when discussing school closures for “under-enrolled” public schools. The district administration, along with the CCS school board, are slamming through closure recommendations and processes without sharing the causes for said under-enrollment.
Not only is the Mifflin High School principal making phone calls and sending emails (with email attachments toeing the line of legality and ethics), but he may be filling out the charter school application for — or at least with — students.
How is it these bosses can work directly against the district’s mission to educate every child and there be no ramifications? How can the cause for under-enrollment be written so plainly, and yet, there’s no call for even pausing to examine the closure list, let alone the reasons behind it?
How can the CCS Mission statement say “we’re preparing every student for success, now and in the future”…by pushing them to charter schools?
Instead of creating the environment necessary for all the city’s children to succeed, building leaders are pushing kids out to pad the graduation rate on the district’s state report card, but the actual benefit is unknown.
I struggle to understand why these principals shoo students out of their own buildings and into charter schools instead of organizing for change in our own district to create and maintain educational settings where all students do have the ability to thrive.
Maybe it’s because CCS really is a dog-eat-dog work environment that causes all workers to live and work in terror, too scared to stand up to anyone above them for fear of retaliation or wrongful termination.
It appears the CCS district administration continues to swing a baseball bat to the kneecaps of their own schools for no other reason than to capitulate to a Republican supermajority that was just trounced in the 2026 midterms.
The main talking point for closing the under-enrolled school buildings in CCS is Senate Bill 311, sponsored by Andrew Brenner (R-Delaware), Chair of the Senate Education Committee. SB 311 would make it state law that a public school operating under 60% of its capacity close its doors.
But that law hasn’t passed yet, and while Statehouse business is a bit busy on Monday and Tuesday of this week, SB 311 isn’t even on the agenda for the House Education Committee yet.
There’s no saying it won’t be pushed through later in the lame duck session, but the CCS Board of Education’s secondary line of defense when it comes to school closures, most often chirped by Board Member Brandon Simmons is the $50 million cut the district “has to make.”
There is no proof closing schools will save money; in fact, I once laid eyes on a public records request that showed not only does the district not have that specific information archived and ready to disseminate, but they also don’t even track it.
If breaking the Republican supermajority and getting Dr. Amy Acton elected as governor was supposed to be monumental for public schools, shouldn’t we at least give our saving graces a chance to throw us a lifeline?
While the newly elected officials cannot simply undo the hemorrhaging of funding to public schools the Republican legislature slit open, surely they can improvise a tourniquet for their public schools before they scrub in for the life-saving surgery to be delivered in the biannual state budget due to be delivered this coming spring 2027.
But surely they will increase our chances of survival while we are on the gurney in the back of the ambulance.
If we can count on the Republican party to beat the life out of us with vouchers, Release Time for Religious Instruction, RIMPs, charter schools, unfunded mandates, and a plummeting funding percentage for 15 years, surely we can count on swift action from officials surfing atop Ohio’s blue wave.…Right?
The high school I work at was in the news recently for finally getting sidewalks with street lighting between the high school and the elementary school, which sit on the same property. I can see the elementary from my classroom windows, their recess bells ring during my lunch.
This sidewalk project took 10 years to complete (celebration pictured above).
Ten. Years.
One sidewalk between an elementary and a high school — who share a campus — took a decade to complete, and the students had to take initiative for it to happen in the first place.
I’m not saying students shouldn’t be politically active or should not learn how to advocate for what they believe in.
I am saying the fact that students had to point out this safety concern in the first place and then wait 10 years for it to be finished is proof our city is not serious about the safety of its children but rather interested in the optics.
Nevertheless, I urge the general public to pause and observe students are currently organizing with a petition to save their school from closure, and students waited a decade for an answer to a letter writing campaign for sidewalks.
Instead of the usual “The kids are alright” social media share, or “There’s hope in the youth” cozy thought of comfort, reflect on the fact children are having to fight for their public school. Children are having to ask (and wait a decade) for sidewalks.
The children of this city deserve more.
PS: Sign the petition.
“Shotgun Chelsea” (Kelsey Gray) is a high school English teacher who believes public officials should be held accountable for the state of public education and the general population should know about it. Her Substack is here.